Showing posts with label Native American. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Native American. Show all posts

Wednesday, 14 January 2026

An unconventional flask from the Arizona desert

What makes an object ‘authentically’ Indigenous? And how can objects challenge our ideas about the history of encounters between Europeans and Indigenous peoples? In this blog article, recent graduate in Visual, Material and Museum Anthropology Olly DeHerrera revisits her research into one of the Museum’s display cases, focussing on the provenance of a painted ceramic flask:

If you walk the stone steps down to the forecourt of the Pitt Rivers Museum, you will find yourself facing Case 153, containing “Pottery - North America”. On the left side of the case, you’ll find this small ceramic water flask, described in the museum’s record as a ‘flat circular pottery flask painted with katsina design’.

Figure 1. 'Flat circular pottery flask painted with katsina design'.
Copyright Pitt Rivers Museum, University of Oxford (1913.87.54)

The flask is recorded as having been made and decorated by a woman named Paelae, with assistance from her daughters, who were members of the Tewa-Hano clan of the Hopi Pueblo Tribe. The Hopi Tribe’s villages are some of the oldest continuously inhabited places in the Americas, situated atop three Mesas (flat-top elevations), six thousand feet above the northern Arizona desert. Today, approximately seven thousand Hopi inhabit the twelve villages of the Hopi Nation. These striking elevated villages and the rich culture of the Hopis were of particular interest to anthropologists of the time. The Hopi are understood to have inspired Alfred Huxley’s depictions of the Native Americans of the ‘Savage Reservation’ in his famous novel A Brave New World.

The flask was collected by Oxford anthropologist Barbara Whitchurch Freire-Marreco. Although her legacy as an anthropologist is modest, Freire-Marreco is remembered as a remarkable, pioneering female anthropologist within Oxford’s Department for Museum Anthropology. As a Research Fellow at Somerville College, she undertook fieldwork in New Mexico and Arizona from 1911-1912, and again in 1913-1914, studying 'the Nature of the Authority of Chiefs and Kings in uncivilised society’. 

Her field notes indicate she spent a significant amount of time with Paelae and her family, purchasing multiple ceramic pieces from them, including this decorative ladle. 

Figure 2. A decorative ladle also made by Paelae and her daughters.
Copyright Pitt Rivers Museum, University of Oxford (1913.87.26)

The Hopi Pueblo are one of the many Indigenous groups inhabiting the arid, mountainous, and rugged terrain of the Southwest (the contemporary States of Utah, New Mexico, Nevada, Arizona, and Western Colorado). Despite being labelled ‘Pottery - North America’, Case 153 contains almost exclusively Pueblo pottery. The Pueblo's centuries-old tradition of producing iconic pottery with geometric designs has found huge popularity with archaeologists, anthropologists, art collectors, and tourists alike. If you have ever visited the American Southwest, there’s a good chance you may have seen some modern Pueblo pottery for sale in National Parks and ‘Trading Post’ gift shops.  

The flask is decorated with the symbol of a Kachina/Katsina, a broad term which describes a series of spiritual figures, or ‘icons’, associated with various natural and supernatural forces in Pueblo cosmology. The Katsina holds feathers in both hands and wears a headdress, a crude depiction of Hopi dancers.

Figure 3. 'Hopi dancers photographed by Freire-Marreco during her fieldwork'.
 
Copyright Pitt Rivers Museum, University of Oxford (1998.95.7)

Although the Katsina represent a legitimate feature of Pueblo culture, the inclusion of such designs on pottery only began appearing around the beginning of the twentieth century. In fact, many of the more decorative and pictographic objects in Case 153 are from this later period in the pottery tradition’s long history. A majority of the older pottery in the case is simple in form and would have had a utilitarian function in a Pueblo household, compared to the more decorative later objects, which vary greatly in form.

So, why had the Pueblo begun adapting their pottery style so dramatically by the start of the twentieth century?

By the time of Freire-Marreco’s arrival in Arizona, the market for Pueblo art was changing rapidly. For the last 150 years prior, Pueblo art had mainly been leaving the Mesas via professional ethnographers - most often associated with institutions like the Bureau of American Ethnology. The three large water vases on the top shelf of Case 153 were collected from the Pueblo by ethnographer James Stevenson in the late 1800s. They were later distributed to the Pitt Rivers Museum by the Smithsonian Institution in 1896. 

Figure 4. One of the three large water jugs displayed in Case 153.
Copyright Pitt Rivers Museum, University of Oxford (1896.54.75)

However, the increase of permanent settlements and the construction of the Santa Fe Railway Line in the twentieth century brought the opportunity for the Pueblo to sell directly to a larger tourist market. The Fred Harvey railway company, which owned the Santa Fe Railway, brought tourists directly into contact with local Indigenous people through the Fred Harvey ‘Indian Tours’. During these tours, Pueblo people were paid to open access to their villages and perform traditional (or at least traditional-looking) ceremonies. Tourists could also purchase directly from Pueblo artists in Fred Harvey’s ‘Indian Shops’. It was during such tours that the American public became familiar with Hopi dances, which was depicted extensively on posters and in handbooks.

Figure 5. ‘Indian Detours’ travel brochure produced by the Fred Harvey Railway Company in 1890. 


The popularity of these tours was driven by romantic colonial ideas about ‘untouched’ humanity living beyond the frontier of American colonial reach. Such ideas about Indigenous societies tend to deny them the same nuanced and complex political histories that we characterise the European past by. It is exactly these romanticised ideas that Huxley invokes in literary form, intentionally contrasting his fictional Native American Society with the hyper-developed and dystopian world of the “World State”.

Objects like the katsina flask represent a form of Pueblo art that arose to appeal to the specific interests of tourists, ethnographers, and other visitors to the American Southwest. Indeed, if Palae intended to create an object appealing to outside observers of Pueblo culture, she was certainly successful. The eye-catching flask has featured in multiple showcasing projects within the Pitt Rivers Museum, including the museum's audio tour that ran throughout the 2010s.

The Katsina flask is actually one of two near-identical flasks purchased from Paelae by Freire-Marreco. If you stand on your tiptoes, you can see the other flask on the middle shelf of the ‘Pottery – Design and Decoration’ case, to the right of the museum’s forecourt. This demonstrates that the Katsina flask was actually one of many produced with this design by Paelae and her family.

A strikingly similar canteen is displayed alongside the Katsina flask, giving the mistaken impression that they are part of a set. In fact, the larger Katsina flask was collected in Arizona by the former Oxford professor, Richard Baxter Townshend, in 1903. Could this have also been made by Paelae and her family? Or could this be evidence that the Pueblo people shared designs in the emergence of a small-scale production?

Figure 6. The Katsina Flask collected by Richard Baxter Townshend.
Copyright Pitt Rivers Museum, University of Oxford (1931.60.13)

These transformations to Pueblo pottery arts were not embraced as keenly by ethnographers as they were by pottery makers. Many anthropologists felt at the time that commercial factors influencing Native American art styles across North America made these objects ‘less Indigenous’, or ‘fake’. In 1889, one American anthropologist angrily wrote, ‘the country is flooded with cheap, and scientifically speaking, worthless earthenware made by the Pueblo Indians to supply the tourist trade' (Holmes, 1889: 320).

So, how should we view our Katsina flask? Is it an example of a ‘worthless fake’, or might we understand it differently in the light of new anthropological approaches?

Despite the problematic colonial undertones of arrangements like the ‘Indian Tours’, the independence that this market afforded the Pueblo was transformative. By achieving greater economic independence, the Hopi were better able to protect their culture, beliefs, and choices about how they wanted to organise themselves as a society in the United States. The choices of Hopi people during this era laid a strong foundation for the Tribe that continues to this day. In fact, many Pueblo people today continue to identify examples of their parents' and grandparents' work stored in museums and express a deep fondness and pride for pottery from this era.

The unconventional anthropological approach that Freire-Marreco took in her fieldwork allows us to access these sorts of perspectives on colonial history.  Her choice to collect objects that her informants were currently making helps us learn more about how the Pueblo made choices to navigate the immense upheaval that colonialism brought to their way of life. These histories provide a counter-narrative to the dominant view of Indigenous people as subjects defined by their lack of intermingling with European ideas and instead highlight their agency and awareness of outside interest in aspects of their culture.

Freire-Marreco’s interactions with her Pueblo informants provide many such insights that the museum is only just beginning to explore. Her ability to see shared humanity and build friendships with Pueblo women led her to declare in a letter to Somerville that the Pueblo were more her research collaborators than ‘uncivilised’ subjects of study. Despite being unable to receive a degree at the time due to her gender, her progressive outlook was far more aligned with the basis of anthropological methodology today.

The Katsina flask offers us a story of how Indigenous people harnessed ethnographic and popular interest in their material culture. By challenging our conceptions about what makes ‘Indigenous art’, we can also challenge popular social narratives about colonial history. It is my hope that anthropologists continue to embrace these stories and seek them out within the museum archives. 


By Olly DeHerrera, Graduate in Visual, Material and Museum Anthropology


Bibliography and further reading:

Dilworth, L. (1996) Imagining Indians in the Southwest : persistent visions of a primitive past. Washington, D.C.; Smithsonian Institution Press.

Fowler, D. D. (2000) A laboratory for anthropology : science and romanticism in the American Southwest, 1846-1930. 1st ed. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.  

Holmes, W H. 1889. 'Debasement of Pueblo Art '. American anthropologist 2(4): 320

Kinsel, R. & E, Poon (2022) Grounded in clay : the spirit of Pueblo pottery. London ; Merrell Publishers. 

Monday, 1 December 2025

‘Made in a Native American style’: Researching the provenance of a reproduction rattle

Taught as part of Oxford University's Visual, Material and Museum Anthropology (VMMA) programme, the 'Provenance Research and the Ethnographic Archive' course provides students with an opportunity to conduct original research on an object, photograph, sound recording or film from the Pitt Rivers Museum's collections. In addition to a full research report, students are invited to write a blog post on their discoveries. 

Here Beatrix Stark (VMMA 2023-2024) writes about her choice, a disc rattle (accession number: 2017.103.48) from the collection of Raymond Wilkes, an English ‘hobbyist’ with a fascination for Native American culture. 

It is unlikely that visitors to the Pitt Rivers Museum will have encountered this rattle before. Since its accession into the museum the rattle has been stored in offsite storage along with objects from the wider Wilkes collection. At first glance the eye is drawn to the bold motifs of two tipis and a buffalo which are painted on the head of the rattle. Even to the untrained eye these motifs, enshrined within popular culture, are associable with Native American culture. 

Figure 1. Reproduction handheld rattle, made in a Native American style, decorated with motifs including a buffalo, a thunderbird and two tipis. 

Copyright Pitt Rivers Museum, University of Oxford (2017.103.48)

2017.103.48  is described on the Pitt Rivers Museum database as a ‘reproduction handheld rattle, made in a Native American style, decorated with motifs including a buffalo, a thunderbird and two tipis’. The frame of the rattle is constructed from a thin piece of wood, measuring 690mm in length and 104mm in width at the rattle's head. The circular head of the rattle has been covered in leather which has been stitched together prior to being painted green around the edges. The faces of the rattle display two different painted motifs: when facing right the rattle head depicts two yellow tipis, a black buffalo and red circular symbol with four spikes radiating from it; the alternate side has a painted red zigzagging border which frames a black thunderbird upon a yellow background. The handle of the rattle is covered in pink felt over which a piece of brown ribbon has been wound. A single feather is attached to the butt of the handle. The rattle makes a noise when shaken as the head contains an ‘indeterminate number’ of loose pellets.


Figure 2. Detail of rattle face depicting two tipis, a buffalo, red circular symbol with spikes radiating from the corners and a thunderbird; alternate rattle face, displaying red zigzag pattern, green edge, and central black thunderbird upon a yellow background.

Copyright Pitt Rivers Museum, University of Oxford (2017.103.48)

The rattle belongs to the Raymond Wilkes collection, a collection of Native American hobbyist material which was donated to the PRM in 2017. The museum accepted the donation as a complement to the Newton Turvey collection, a hobbyist collection acquired by the PRM in 1998. It is uncertain whether Wilkes made or collected the rattle and if the geographical location of its production was North America, Canada or the United Kingdom. The rattle is not comparable in style or form to any of the rattles currently held within the PRM collections. 

Raymond Wilkes was a twentieth-century English Native American hobbyist living in the West Midlands. The term ‘hobbyist’ is used to describe often white, non-indigenous people who have a fascination with Native American culture. Hobbyists are actively involved in researching Native American history, reproducing aspects of its material culture and staging historical re-enactments. During the mid-twentieth century Wilkes was one of ‘less than a dozen people in Britain to not only participate in reproduction and re-enactment but to make a serious study of the North American Indian’ (“Ten days with the Sioux Tribe”). 

Native American hobbyism emerged from the long history of cultural ‘criss-crossing’ that has taken place since the European ‘discovery’ of the New World (Deloria 1998:129). During the Boston Tea Party on December 16, 1773, American patriots disguised themselves as ‘Mohawk Indians’, drawing an affinity between American and Indigenous identity, as a means of asserting the legitimacy of settler colonial land rights. During the nineteenth century the mass transfer of Native American peoples onto reservations gave rise to popular entertainment in the form of ethnic shows. Native Americans such as Sitting Bull were paid to leave reservations to perform the role of ‘Indian’ in Buffalo Bill’s Wild West show, a series of dramatized re-enactments of American history, that toured Europe between 1887-1892 and 1902-1906. Elements of Native American culture were further assimilated within popular culture through the social movement of the Boy Scouts. By the twentieth century ‘Cowboy and Indian’ movies, evolving from the nineteenth-century Wild West Show, had seeped into European popular culture, enshrining a romanticised image of the vanished ‘Native American’ within the collective imagination.

A key characteristic which defines hobbyism is the movement's commitment to ‘authenticity’. Within the context of hobbyism, ‘authenticity’ is defined as ‘attention to material detail and the use of “traditional” materials and techniques’ (Peers 2025). Therefore, despite the decontextualising process inherent in hobbyism, in which material culture from different indigenous groups and periods are assembled, objects made by non-indigenous people using traditional techniques and materials, are considered by hobbyists to be equal in authenticity to those made by indigenous peoples.

Figure 3. 'From The Days of the Wild West', Raymond Wilkes displaying items from his Native American and hobbyist collection. 2017.103 Supplementary Information, Manuscripts and Collections Department, Pitt Rivers Museum, Oxford. 

Confronted with limited archival information regarding the rattle, a core method of provenance work is to expand research beyond the immediate institution. The widespread digitisation of museum collections allowed me to expand my search to the online collections of the National Museum of the American Indian (NMAI), located within the Smithsonian Institution, Washington DC. 

A simple search for the term ‘rattle’ on the NMAI database returned a range of rattles which displayed a similar form and motifs. The available provenance information states that many of the rattles were made circa late nineteenth and early twentieth century, accessioned or collected in the early to mid-twentieth century and geographically from North America, Canada. I contacted a curator at the NMAI who told me that these items are termed “disc rattles” or “flat disc rattles” and were made by several First Nations groups in Canada and some tribal groups on the US Northern Plains. Rattles may have been used for ritual or musical purposes, important not only for ‘extra-musical affects’ but because ‘their presence contributes to the symbolic meanings associated with the materials from which they were made, as well as the purpose of the song’ (“The Challenges of Collecting North America”). The curator suggested that Native American people may have made and sold undecorated rattles, to non-indigenous people such as hobbyists or boy scouts who subsequently painted them. 

Flat disc rattles, widespread from ‘the Eastern Anishnabe area through central and on to the north-western regions of Canada’ are made from a flat stick looped back on itself and covered in rawhide (“Rattle Construction”). Plains disc rattles predominantly use hide from the ‘buffalo pericardium’ whereas the Tlicho (Dogribs) are more likely to use ‘caribou skin parchment’ (“Rattle Construction”). The motif of the buffalo on the PRM rattle could therefore be indicative of the rattle being inspired by Plains disc rattles. Rattles within the Metropolitan Museum of Art also display the motif of the tipi, however I am yet to find rattles which also display the motifs of a buffalo and thunderbird. More elaborate in design, the PRM rattle appears to be a copy of earlier rattles which were indigenous made.

Although it is not possible from this brief comparison to define the provenance of the rattle it provides a glimpse into the production of ‘sacred’ objects for the European market. The PRM rattle was potentially inspired by a rattle that had undergone multiple layers of cultural mediation – having been decorated with the intention of being sold to the European market or subsequently decorated post purchase. Increasing the quantity of comparisons may provide insights into why the motifs of the tipi, thunderbird and buffalo were chosen beyond their totemic significance within Native American culture. 

By the 1880s the movement of Native American peoples onto reservations signalled the completion of the settler colonial land grab. Native American ‘depopulation’ peaked in 1910 with the population falling to ‘circa 200,000’ – in an epoch defined by the supplanting of the American identity over indigenous identities (Green 1988: 37). However, the notion that Native Americans were wiped out by settler colonialism has been used to perpetuate the myth of the ‘vanished’ Native American. Green states that during the early twentieth century ‘for one brief moment in space and time, it appear[ed] to most Americans that, indeed, this species [Native Americans] will go the way of the buffalo, leaving the stage clear for an unobstructed stage for playing Indian’ (Green 1988: 37). This lends a new poignancy to the rattle’s motifs which, in their stereotypical form, presence an imagined absence. 

The ambiguity of what defines an object as ‘authentic’ is exemplified by the hobbyist collections within the PRM. For example, should objects from the Newton Turvey collection which were begun by indigenous people before being finished by Turvey (a hobbyist) be considered more authentic than objects entirely produced by hobbyists? If the authenticity of an object is linked to the indigeneity of their maker does this also hold true for objects that were made by Indigenous people for the European market but not used for ritual purposes?

The myth of the vanishing Native American, and the stereotypical imagery associated with Native American culture, prevents the identities and voices of First Nations and diasporic Native American communities from being seen and heard. 

The rattle could be used as an entry point for thinking through notions of cultural identity by engaging with the Native American diaspora in the UK. The rattle, as a hybrid object, presences the imaginary space between worlds, unsettling any straightforward understanding of the term ‘authentic.’ 


By Beatrix Stark, Graduate in Visual, Material and Museum Anthropology


References Cited 

Deloria, P. 1998.  Playing Indian. New Haven : Yale University Press.

Green, R.1988. ‘The Tribe Called Wannabee: Playing Indian in America and Europe’, Folklore, 99 (1), pp. 30–55.

“Rattle Construction” excerpt from ‘The Culture of the Drum’, Native Drum <shttps://iportal.usask.ca/sites/iportal.usask.ca/files/content/add/1H%20-%20Rattle%20Construction%20-%20Some%20Examples.pdf>[accessed 2 April 2025]. 

L Peers 2025, pers. comms.

“The Challenges of Collecting North America, Continued: The Sioux and the Smithsonian - the Metropolitan Museum of Art.” Metmuseum.org, 14 Oct. 2014, www.metmuseum.org/perspectives/collecting-north-america-2. Accessed 30 Mar. 2025.

‘Ten days with the Sioux Tribe’, MERCIAN, 2017.103 Supplementary Information, Manuscripts and Collections Department, Pitt Rivers Museum, University of Oxford.






Friday, 2 May 2025

The Keam Sherds in the Museum





Figure 1:Four pottery sherds 1922.35.118 – 1922.35.121 (front)

To many museum visitors and researchers alike, ancient pottery sherds may not inspire any meaningful insight into contemporary Indigenous culture and communities. Historically, these sorts of archaeological specimens have been considered ‘common objects’ and are abundant in institutional collections across the globe. However, researching closely with this set of pottery sherds reveals a concealed cosmology of thought and identity from the desert region of the American Southwest. 

A set of four pottery sherds, described in the museum database simply as ‘4 sherds, possibly Mesa Verde grey ware of the Four Corners region’, Arizona, Southwestern USA. Whilst their age and broad location indicates they are fragments of clay pottery made by the ancestral Puebloans (AD 100 – 1600), their status as objects of cultural importance and institutional interest far exceeds their material property. The intention of this blog post is to consider the Keam sherds in the wider context of their biographical history, their diverse and often divisive affordances both within the museum and outside of it, and the potential for decolonial thinking in partnership with them. 

Figure 2: Four pottery sherds 1922.35.118 – 1922.35.121 (back)

The sherds arrived in the Pitt Rivers in 1922, sent by Walter Hough, the head curator of the Smithsonian Museum, to the Pitt Rivers’ first curator, Henry Balfour. Six other objects acquired in this same donation are currently on display in the Pottery – North America case (c.153.A) on the ground floor of the Pitt Rivers Museum. This includes an ‘ancient’ pottery ladle from Keams Canyon (1922.35.1), three small ‘ancient’ pottery bowls from an unspecified area of Arizona (1922.35.2), (1922.35.4), (1922.35.8). An ‘ancient’ ceramic jug from a similarly unspecified area of Arizona (1922.35.6), and a ‘modern’ pottery jar from either the Walpi or Owachomo Pueblo Village (1922.35.3). 

Inscribed prominently onto the sherds are the words ‘Keams Canyon’, giving some insight into their location of origin. Somewhat misleadingly, Keams Canyon refers not to a canyon itself, but an area of land settled and homesteaded by the Keam family on the modern-day Hopi Nation, in the North-East of Arizona. An array of notable archaeologists and ethnologists collected at Keams Canyon, including Cosmos and Victor Mindeleff in 1882 on behalf of the Bureau of Ethnology, as well as James and Matilda Coxe Stevenson who worked in the area beginning 1879. Thomas Keam himself also sold objects to the Smithsonian , the Peabody Museum, and many other museums within America.   

Figure 3: Smithsonian Accession records containing mention of ‘fragments of pottery (mixed)’ obtained from ’12 miles north of Keams Canyon’ by James Steveson in 1885. 

Whilst thousands of sherds are recorded as being collected by different archaeologists and ethnologists in the area, it is impossible to discern who is indeed responsible for the collection of the Keam sherds. There is also the possibility that the Keam sherds were not collected by Keam or any of the collectors visiting the site, but by the mostly unnamed Indigenous people who guided and aided ethnologists and archaeologists in the Americas. This history is complicated and tied to a frenzy of ethnographic collecting which occurred throughout the 17th and 18th Century, through which many objects found themselves in the Pitt Rivers Museum. 

Figure 4: Local Navajo men assisting Walter Hough’s team of archaeologists in an excavation at the Jettyo Valley.  

Source: Hough, W. (1903) Archaeological field work in northeastern Arizona. The Museum-Gates Expedition of 1901: Govt. print. off. p.252 

Whilst these collaborations in collecting may appear positive, it is important to remember that the unequal power relations which occur under colonialism require this history to be viewed critically. In a report on the 1901 Museum-Gates Expedition in the region of Keams Canyon, Walter Hough writes: 

‘Lack of water, however, has not prevented the Navaho tearing the Jettyto ruins to pieces in search of pottery for the trader [Thomas Keam]’. 

This image of the looting of an ancestral landscape by Indigenous people is difficult, but such histories are part of the very fabric of ethnographic collecting and its deep ties to colonial regimes. To this day, Indigenous people continue to have little control over how their material culture is displayed and talked about in museums. Beyond the many possibilities behind the collection of the Keam sherds, it is important to remember that the contemporary Indigenous people of the region may challenge the legitimacy of all collecting done under the unequal power relations of colonialism. 

Figure 5. A photograph of the inside of the Trading Post at Keams Canyon, taken late 19th Century and recovered from a box of mixed prints in the British Museum archive.  

Photograph provided by The Trustees of the British Museum, available at: https: ://www.britishmuseum.org/collection/object/EA_Am-B34-15 © The Trustees of the British Museum.  



The influence of archaeology on anthropological thinking is highly visible within the Pitt Rivers Museum, an overlap of a historical field often described as ‘ethnoarchaeology’. The collection of Hough’s pottery which is displayed in the North America Pottery case is a product of much of this so called ethnoarchaeological thinking which combined anthropological ideas about societies with archaeological ideas about the deep past. When the potsherds are described in terms of ‘specimen’, these ideas are imposed onto them, and they come to represent ethnoarchaeological ideas about American antiquity and historic academic beliefs about the so-called ‘development’ of Native American society. 

Today, the Pitt Rivers acknowledges that the language of labels which appear in the collection may not appropriately or accurately reflect the knowledge that source communities themselves hold about these objects. Instead, what these labels often reflect is historic academic attitudes and academic ideas that harmfully, and occasionally intentionally, contradict with Indigenous understandings of self and history. 

The cultural significance of pottery within the landscape will be visible to anyone who has visited Tribal lands in the Southwest, where potsherds are intentionally and consciously left upon the ground; occasionally grouped together to be viewed, but firmly within the land. Indigenous voices in the American Southwest advocate strongly for the protection of this material, and the important role of ancestral material culture within the landscape. 

‘Those artifacts represent more than just remnants: so much labor mixed with the surroundings by the ancestors of the indigenous inhabitants’ Kimball Bighorse (Navajo/Cayuga). 

For many Indigenous people living in the region, knowledge and memory of their ancestors is preserved within the landscape and the artefacts left there by their ancestors, who are known as Histat’sinom (people of long ago), in the Hopi language. 

 

‘Protection of the landscape allows us to share with the outside world that we are more than historical footnotes, to show that our connections to the ancestral land traverse distance and time’ Lyle Balenquah (Hopi). 

To Indigenous societies of the region, ancestral objects are valued for the connection they can provide to the ancestors, and the removal of these objects presents a serious violation of that relationship. The removal of the Keam sherds and the lack of information recorded about their biographic history is therefore frustrating in many ways. The Keam sherds are a small representation of many objects within the Pitt Rivers Museum which are characterized institutionally by an absence of records, and they remind us that colonial violence presents itself in different forms. Within the Pitt Rivers Museum, the reminders of colonial violence can be seen in blatant ways, such as the burn marks on the rear of an Ivory Tusk from the Kingdom of Benin, but they can also reveal themselves in these vast absences and silences. 

The task of giving voice to the Keam sherds is an almost paradoxical one of applying restitution to an object that has become ‘lost’ whilst we are able to hold it in our hands. The locality of these ancestral objects is deeply important to Indigenous people for whom they afford an irreplaceable connection to the ancestors. The violation of this relationship through collecting is therefore a harm caused by the collectors.  

Perhaps a hopeful outlook is to consider how the Keam sherds can continue to be teaching objects as they were in their homeland by inviting us to look differently at the space of the museum. The Keam sherds expose how violence against Indigenous people is not always obvious physical violence and can instead take the form of the erasure of Indigenous knowledge and the removal of sacred objects. It is this sort of violence that remains the most sustained within institutions like the Pitt Rivers, making the Keam sherds not just evidence of a violent history but witness to an ongoing one.  

The Keam sherds also remind us that some wounds cannot be fully healed, and decolonisation is not a process of total reversal. Perhaps it is better to suggest that the Keam sherds encourage us to sit with discomfort and to take seriously the harm done by museum institutions. Afterall, to acknowledge and to frustrate over these impossibilities is to share- in small part- in the Indigenous experience itself. With this acknowledged, there is optimism that the Keam sherds may now inform people about the many different ways of knowing and being experienced by people in the world. With the Keam Sherds this should perhaps best begin with how Indigenous people of the Southwest show reverence to ancestral objects: in the presence of great forces of ancestors is the invitation to sit quietly and to think. 

By Olly DeHerrera

Graduate of Visual, Material and Museum Anthropology at the University of Oxford.


Further reading: 

 

Colwell, C. (John S. (2010) Living histories : Native American issues and Southwestern archaeology. Lanham, MD: Altamira Press. 

 

Hicks, D. & Stevenson, Alice. (2013) World archaeology at the Pitt Rivers Museum : a characterization. Oxford: Archaeopress. 

Keeler, J. (ed.) (2017) Edge of morning : native voices speak for the Bears Ears. First Torrey House Press edition. Salt Lake City, Utah: Torrey House Press. 

 

Peers, L. & Brown, A. K. (2015) Visiting with the ancestors: Blackfoot shirts in museum spaces. Edmonton, Alberta: Athabasca University Press.